proven HIV harm reduction strategies like needle
exchange and in avoiding specific reference to target
populations like commercial sex workers. But
according to an NGO observer, few conservative
groups attended, and both PEPFAR and the Bush
administrations emphasis on abstinence-until-mar-
riage perspective were criticized by other nations at
the gathering.
The strength of the final declaration was dimin-
ished, not so much by challenges to language, but by
the assemblys unwillingness to be more ambitious
in its commitments to fighting HIV/AIDS.
Even when the Bush Administration fails to
change the content of international declarations, the
power of the purse gives the United States consider-
able influence over many
international programs. In
2003 and again in 2005, the
U.S. House of Represen-
tatives blocked $500 mil-
lion in international family
planning funds destined for
the United Nations Popu-
lation Fund (UNFPA), falsely
claiming that the funds
would go to Chinese women
aborting pregnancies to
comply with Chinas one family, one child popula-
tion policy.35 In 2002, the United States also froze $3
million in aid to the World Health Organization,
because the UN agency conducts research on safe
abortion techniques.
A Bumpy Road
E
fforts to insert an anti-choice platform at the UN
have been uneven. In 2001, when Bush overruled
then Secretary of State Colin Powell by attempting to
appoint John Klink to be the Assistant Secretary of
State for Population, Refugees, and Migration, the
plan collapsed in the face of widespread criticism.
Klink had been the Vaticans representative at the
UN for six years and was an opponent of condom
use for HIV prevention and reproductive health serv-
ices for refugee women. At a February 2005 confer-
ence marking the 10th anniversary of the Beijing
Conference on the Status of Women, official U.S. del-
egates failed in their effort to remove references to
the right to reproductive health on the grounds it
referred to abortion rights but still reaffirmed sup-
port for the declarations made in Beijing.36
But all was not lost for anti-choice supporters.
During the January 2006 Congressional holiday
recess, Bush appointed the chief of the U.S. delega-
tion, Ellen Sauerbrey, a former Bush campaign
worker and anti-choice representative at the UN, to
the State Department position he tried to fill with
John Klink. Like other
recess appointments, this
one occurred without the
conventional approval of
Congress. Womens health
and human rights advocates
worldwide expressed out-
rage, but the deed was done.
Since her appointment,
Sauerbrey has been im-
mersed in refugee issues and
has not been visible at UN
events dealing with reproductive rights.
In November of 2005 the UN Human Rights
Committee (UNHRC), an 18-member group that
monitors the implementation of the UNs human
rights covenants, decided in its first abortion case,
KL v. Peru, that abortion is a human right. This
decision affirmed the work of international womens
health advocates who have been describing the dis-
crimination and deprivation many women experi-
ence across the globe as the result solely of their
being women.
The UNHRC decision sent anti-choice NGOs
into tailspins. Austin Ruse stubbornly declared in
his Friday Fax that the committees decision was not
only an example of flawed reasoning but was also
non-binding.37
UNd o i n g R e p r o d u c t i v e Fr e e d o m Christian Right NGOs Target the United Nations
POLITICAL RESEARCH ASSOCIATES 2006
10
Even when the Bush
Administration fails to change
the content of international
declarations, the power of the
purse gives the United States
considerable influence over
many international programs.
35U.S. Department of State, Report of the China UN Population Fund (UNPFA) Independent Assessment Team,
May 29, 2002, http://www.state.gov/g/prm/rls/rpt/2002/12122.htm.
36Goldenberg, Suzanne. American Urges UN to Renounce Abortion Rights. Guardian, March 1, 2005.
http://www.globalpolicy.org/empire/un/2005/0301abortion.htm.
37C-Fam Friday Fax, December 9, 2005, at http://www.c-fam.org/FAX/Volume_8/faxv8n51.html.