| Estimating Likelihood of Approved Discriminatory Activity for
Each Type of Biased Belief Structure .
Bias can be based on perceptions of
ethnicity, race, national origin, religion, creed, gender, sexual orientation,
age, class, disability
|
Non
Discriminator |
Mild
Discrimination |
Strong
Discriminator |
Abusive
Threatening |
Violent |
Murderous |
Genocidal |
Non
Prejudiced |
++++++++++ |
+++ |
++ |
+ |
. |
. |
. |
Mildly
Prejudiced |
+++++++ |
++++++++++ |
+++++ |
++ |
+ |
. |
. |
Strongly
Prejudiced |
+++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
+++ |
++ |
. |
. |
Mildly
Ideological |
++ |
+++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++ |
+++ |
. |
. |
| Strongly Ideological |
++ |
++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++ |
+++++ |
+ |
. |
Mildly
Supremacist |
+ |
++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++ |
+++++++ |
++ |
. |
Strongly
Supremacist |
. |
+++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
+++ |
+ |
Mildly
Hateful |
. |
++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++ |
++ |
Strongly
Hateful |
. |
+ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++ |
++++ |
Expulsionist
. |
. |
. |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++ |
++++++ |
Eliminationist
. |
. |
. |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
++++++++++ |
.
Chip Berlet - Political Research Associates - 1998
.
This chart is an expanded version of a concept suggested in Peter I. Rose, They
and We: Racial and Ethnic Relations in the United States, (New York:
Random House, 1966).
Notes to Chart:
Bias and discrimination are based on perceptions of race, religion,
ethnicity, gender, or sexual identity. The facts are seldom as important
as the perceptions.
Here we define hateful persons as those who support the denial of basic
rights and liberties to members of a demonized group. Persons who are
hateful are often ideological or supremacist or both, but sometimes are
motivated solely by strong prejudice.
An ideological stance is one where the belief structure is more than
a package of notions or inclinations but a set of ideas that represent
an attempt to explain reality--a worldview. Ideological ideas are "isms." Thus
racism, sexism, antisemtism, heterosexism, etc.
Some persons who are prejudiced (and a few who hold ideological or supremacist
views) still refuse to engage in discrimination as a matter of principle.
Why "Approved Activity" instead of actual activity? Many bias-motivated
attacks are carried out by persons with no direct ties to ideological,
supremacist, or hate groups, but who have internalized ideas common in
the culture or ideas being circulated in the community under stress in
which they live. Also, demagogues in ideological groups often count on
local young men (13-25 years old) to actually carry out acts of discrimination
or violence.
Why would non-prejudiced people still discriminate? Because of peer
pressure in their community.
Prejudiced persons often do not have a coherent ideological basis for
their beliefs, while persons with coherent ideological or supremacist
views can be defending their power and privilege without having prejudged
the group they seek to oppress.
Demonization often leads to scapegoating. Conspiracist allegations claiming
a targeted group is plotting against the common good is a specific form
of scapegoating.
Expulsionism, separatism, and segregationism are distinct yet related
belief structures. Expulsionists here are assumed to be supremacists
as well, but there is an emerging separatist ideology which calls for
racially-homogenous nation states. As an intellectual current, racial
separatism claims not to be supremacist. In practice, it is most often
put forward by groups with a supremacist ideology. It most often appears
as a form of racial nationalism that calls for racial separatism, including
a variety of fascism called the Third Position. In the United States
groups promoting racial separatism include White Aryan Resistance and
a variety of other neo-nazi formations, the Liberty Lobby, the Nation
of Islam, and the Republic of New Africa. Separatism in this chart would
be included under the "Strongly Ideological" belief structure. Segregationists
would range from "Strongly Ideological" to "Strongly Prejudiced."
Antisemitism has a durable and unique history of appearing at various
times as a form of bias based on perceptions of religion, ethnicity,
and race. While Jews are not of a single race, their biased critics often
project on them a racial coherence that has been a powerful motivating
force for discrimination.
The following holds true for all varieties of prejudice and oppression.
Replace [antisemitism] with any form of oppression such as [racism] or
[sexism] to see the universal validity of the argument. With different
forms of oppression, the example groups would also change.
People can be consciously [antisemitic] and overt about it. Such as
White Aryan Resistance.
People can be consciously [antisemitic] but covert about it. Such as
Liberty Lobby and Spotlight.
People can be unconsciously [antisemitic], but fail to see it and deny
it. Such as Pat Buchanan.
People can be unintentionally [antisemitic] by promoting ideas or policies
that have the effect of perpetuating antisemitism. Such as Pat Robertson. |